Member review

An excellent film portraying Turins character, live and times. Although I appreciate the writers freedom and use of poetic license, I found that there were several historical indesrepencies which I could not ignore.

Cumberbatch was perfectly cast for the role, with his ability to portray the character of Turin and his multiple insecurities. I have rated this film such, as I believe that parts of the film may have been over-dramatised with an experienced use of real life footage mixed with (although a slightly adapted version of) the re-enacted moments in Bletchleys past. The directors made clever use of a real life Enigma machine, however I feel that not removing the museums explanation plaque from the inside of its lid in some far off shots, was a mistake, I am pleased to say that in all close-ups it had been removed. Despite the lack of visible action, this film clearly portrayed the effect Bletchley had on the British war effort however it was more focused on Turin and his colleagues. The facts have truly been, if slightly warped in places, stuck to and the moving part of the film is not necessarily Turin's contribution at Bletchley but him being persecuted in spite of this, this shows how the official secrets act, although it protected many aspects of British intelligence, left many of its assets exposed to persicution despite their true patriotism. The music was well used although it only appeared on rare occasions in the main part where there was no dialogue. Although I understand why the changes in reality were made in order to impress a general audience, I am upset that they did not allow the film to cater for the more specialist audience.

My opinion is that the film although interesting should have been more historically accurate. I did however find it enjoyable and is certainly a film I would recommend to my friends and watch again. This is my second time viewing the film, having initially viewed it at the cinema, I was therefore able to watch it more analytically than for pure enjoyment. Once again I would like to praise Cumberbatch's excellent performance and the subtle elegance of the film.