Member review

When I first heard about The Artist, I expected a nostalgic and creative homage to silent cinema. The idea of a modern film recreating the silent, black-and-white style of the 1920s seemed intriguing.

The film follows George Valentin, a successful silent film star whose career plummets with the advent of “talkies.” Meanwhile, Peppy Miller, a young actress George once helped, rises to fame as the new face of sound films. The plot explores George’s struggle with obsolescence and pride, alongside Peppy’s desire to help him. The storyline is simple and easy to follow, which fits the conventions of silent cinema, where visuals and music carry the narrative. Its dedication to silent film techniques is admirable but sometimes makes the pacing feel slow and repetitive.

I didn’t enjoy The Artist as much as I had hoped, the film didn’t engage me emotionally. The lack of dialogue sometimes made the characters’ emotions feel overly exaggerated or one-dimensional, and the absence of natural sound throughout most of the film made it feel painfully boring at times. That said, the production design, costumes, and attention to detail in recreating the silent film era are impressive.

One scene that stood out to me is George’s dream sequence, where diegetic sounds like a phone ringing and a dog barking suddenly intrudes into his silent world. The sequence effectively conveys George’s fear of irrelevance and his discomfort with the new era of sound films. The exaggerated sounds and George’s silent scream create a chaotic, unsettling atmosphere, encouraging the audience to feel his growing panic and helplessness. This scene showcases the filmmaker’s ability to use sound and silence creatively to evoke emotion.

Despite its artistic achievements, I wouldn’t recommend The Artist to general audiences. It may appeal to film historians or those who love silent cinema and want to see it revived in a modern context. However, for casual viewers, the film’s slow pace, and lack of dialogue will feel boring and underwhelming. While it has its moments, The Artist ultimately fell short of delivering a truly captivating experience for me.